1. Christian Bale - Patrick Bateman - American Psycho - Yup, I honestly do think this is the best acting job I've ever seen, Christian Bale is freakishly perfect playing pseudo-psycho killer Patrick Bateman, pretty much every note in this huge part is played with amazing consistency and perfection, Bale is funny when he's supposed to be, scary when he's supposed to be, everything is just perfect. Bale is perfect in a movie where nearly every sequence could be dissected and taught in any filmmaking class. This was a case where I think the actor chosen had to be a relative unknown and had to have massive talent to make it work, name me another actor who could have even attempted this role. Kevin Spacey? Maybe, but I think it would have been too one-note creepy, Guy Pierce? Could have worked OK but I think Christian has more of what is needed in every category than Guy, anyone else? (let's all remember for a moment that for a while this was a Leonardo D vehicle, wow)
Movie: 10/10
Portrayal: 10/10
Best Line: 'I just had to kill a lot of people!' (among about 50 great lines)
2. Dwight Yoakum - Doyle Hargraves - Sling Blade - I have admit first off that I have a soft spot for Dwight, I love him in every role I've ever seen him in, this just happens to be the best one. He plays this very not nice guy like a beaten puppy who's grown up into a very dangerous dog who isn't hard at all but rather is way, way too soft, every action that could possibly be read as an act against him immediately causes him to seek to hurt and intimidate whoever is closest to him. The movie has a few faults (the small townyness feels much less real and more staged than something like 'Boys Don't Cry') but Dwight is the perfect lurker in every scene he has, promising you that he'll hurt you if you would just give him a chance.
Movie: 8/10
Portrayal: 10/10
Best Line: several; 'I'm just kidding.' 'Let's all just sit here and be a family. Until your mentally retarded friend and your homosexual friend get here.'
3. Sean Astin - Samwise Gamgee - LOTR - I have to admit that I didn't think Sean had it in him. I think this was the case of a role fitting perfectly within the somewhat narrow breadth of an actors abilities. Samwise was the only character that made me cry more than once and was easily the character I was watching for and being led by. Sean Astin has always seemed to me to be the definition of a purely good, positive, if slightly limited person, Samwise is all this is every scene.
Movie: 9/10
Portrayal:10/10
Best Line: 'I made a promise, Mr Frodo. A promise. "Don't you leave him Samwise Gamgee." And I don't mean to. I don't mean to.'
4. Guy Pierce - Leonard Shelby - Memento - Every other actor I can think of would have failed in this role. Guy juggles the huge number of things going on with his character so perfectly that the machinery of his acting is never even hinted at, if this role had been played by most any other young actor I think the groan of effort would have been all over it.
Movie: 9/10
Portrayal: 10/10
Best Line: 'OK, what am I doing? I'm chasing this guy... Nope, he's chasing me.'
5. Frances McDormond - Marge Gunderson - Fargo - Holy crap is she good! Hilarious, touching, smart, caring, determined, all while being very, very pregnant, Frances makes the character more like a real person than perhaps any other I can think of. I'd rather have Perry Mason on my case than Marge Gunderson any day.
Movie: 7.5/10
Portrayal: 9/10
Best Line: 'I'm not sure I agree with you a hundred percent on your police work, there, Lou.'
6. Orson Wells - Police Captain Hank Quinlan - Touch of Evil - I mean come on! It's big fat Orson in a bigger, fatter fat suit, he's simply amazing, intimidating as hell as a completely believable hard, hard sheriff. In a movie too smart to have a real 'bad' guy he's the closest thing, but the movie has enough brains to take even the sheriff aside for a few scenes to show he's not really all that bad a guy. Orson left Hollywood for good when they wouldn't, or couldn't accept a movie as far ahead of it's time as Touch of Evil.
Movie: 9/10
Portrayal: 9/10
Best Line: commenting on his weight 'It's either the candy or the hooch. I must say, I wish it was your chili I was gettin' fat on. Anyway, you're sure lookin' good.'
7. Mark Ruffalo - Terry Prescott - You Can Count On Me - As an actor Mark Ruffalo rumbles with emotion, this performance is the only one on the list that is possibly above Frances McDormond's Marge as a believable 'real world' character. The list of adjectives that apply to the Terry is so long, there are hardly any that don't fit; from pathetic to caring to petty to sweet they are all shown in perfect balance by Ruffalo. I cannot believe that this role didn't get Oscar attention, oh wait, yes I can. You know that Ruffalo knows how bad, and even dangerous, Terry's great ideas are but he skillfully never lets so much as a wink show through to the audience, this is a selfless actor playing a selfish character who wants to be better so long as it doesn't require much effort, sacrifice or discipline from him.
Movie: 8/10
Portrayal: 8.5/10
Best Line: 'We're going fishing.'
8. Adam Sandler - Barry Egan - Punch Drunk Love - I know I know, don't take my head off, it's a sloppy, goofy role, it's also completely believable, when Barry ducks back around the corner of his warehouse after meeting Emily Watson because his OCD is going into overload, or when he snaps and starts smashing windows or when he trashes a bathroom or when he calls a phone sex line it's all stunningly realized by Sandler's choice of how to play the role. The scene of him stomping around the warehouse with Jon Brion's amazing score reduced to pounding drums as Barry edges closer and closer to who knows what is one of my favorite scenes in any movie ever. Yes, most of his comedies are stupid wastes of time and no, I am not the least bit surprised that he had this in him.
Movie: 9/10
Portrayal: 9/10
Best Line: tie; 'I beat up the bathroom.' 'I have a love in my life, it makes me stronger than anything you can imagine.'
9. Sigourney Weaver - Ellen Ripley - Aliens - In Aliens, much more so than in Alien, or those other two similar but awful movies that followed, Sigourney's stunningly tough but human portrayal of a regular person forced to become extraordinary or die is a serious cut above every other action movie hero I have ever seen. She's not playing an action hero doing flips and hyper-fast fighting to beat the bad guys, she's a normal person backing away from trouble, gun ready, checking her instruments and looking for a way out. The chills in my back the first time I saw the film when I first realized she was going back for Newt stick with me to this day.
Movie: 8/10
Portrayal: 8/10
Best Line: 'Get away from her, you BITCH!'
10. Hilary Swank - Teena Brandon/Brandon Teena - Boys Don't Cry - I know it's a big tear jerking sad role, it's also true and riveting and horrifying, if it were fiction it would be dismissed on any number of faults, as a true story it has all it needs to. I have never seen so much pain on the screen in any other movie. This spot should almost go to Hilary Swank and Chloe Sevengy as a team as they continually one-up each other revealing depths to the characters.
Movie: 7/10
Portrayal: 8/10
Best Line: 'I hate your life too.'